ADVERTISING & MARKETING
How Modern CPA Booked 30 Meetings With Accounting Firm Partners and Had to Hire Another Sales Rep to Keep Up
~10 meetings per month
meetings booked in 3 months
Reply Rate
Outbound channel used
CLIENT REVIEW
Hear it straight from the client

Martin Popiel
CEO at MODERNCPA
THE CHALLENGE
Where they were stuck
Modern CPA (now FirmOS) helps accounting firms grow through structured marketing systems. Their challenge was reaching managing partners at CPA firms, conservative buyers who move slowly, distrust marketing promises, and personally control marketing decisions at their practices.
Managing partners are conservative buyers who distrust marketing agency promises
Accounting firm decision-makers move slowly and require high-credibility outreach
Internal pipeline generation was insufficient to support growth targets
THE SYSTEM WE BUILT
How we solved their problems
Identify Growth-Ready Firms
Targeted managing partners at firms with 3 to 10 CPAs, a sweet spot where the practice is large enough to invest in growth but small enough that the managing partner still makes marketing decisions personally. Growth signals like recent hiring activity and new service line announcements helped identify firms in active growth mode.
Anchor on Verified Outcomes
Cold email messaging anchored on a specific, verifiable outcome: Modern CPA's clients adding $500K+ in recurring revenue. That number was specific enough to be credible and large enough to command attention from a partner who measures success in billable hours and client retention.
Scale With Multi-Channel
LinkedIn outreach targeted managing partners with engagement focused on practice management and firm growth discussions. AI cold calling reached partners at larger firms using peer-level scripts that positioned conversations as strategy discussions rather than sales pitches. The combined pressure generated enough pipeline to require hiring another sales rep.
Accounting firm managing partners are conservative buyers who move slowly and distrust marketing promises. That makes outbound in this space a patience game built on credibility. Modern CPA (now FirmOS) needed a reliable pipeline of conversations with these decision-makers without resorting to the generic agency pitches that get immediately deleted.
The targeting focused on managing partners at firms with 3 to 10 CPAs, a sweet spot where the practice is large enough to invest in growth but small enough that the partner still makes marketing decisions personally. Growth signals like recent hiring activity and new service line announcements helped identify firms in active growth mode rather than those content with their current book of business.
Cold email messaging anchored on a specific, verifiable outcome: Modern CPA's clients adding $500K+ in recurring revenue. That number was specific enough to be credible and large enough to command attention from a partner who measures success in billable hours and client retention. LinkedIn outreach targeted the same managing partners with engagement focused on practice management content. AI cold calling served as a third channel for partners at larger firms, using peer-level scripts that positioned conversations as strategy discussions rather than sales pitches.
The multi-channel pressure worked: the campaign hit a 24% reply rate and booked 30 meetings in 3 months, generating so much inbound demand that Modern CPA had to hire another sales rep to handle the pipeline. As CEO Martin Popiel put it: "Call volume has gone up significantly. We had to hire another Sales Rep."
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Common questions about this case study, answered.
How do you reach managing partners at accounting firms with cold outreach?
By leading with specific, verifiable outcomes rather than marketing promises. Modern CPA's campaign anchored on clients adding $500K+ in recurring revenue, a number credible enough for data-driven CPAs. Combined with multi-channel outreach, this approach hit a 24% reply rate and booked 30 meetings in 3 months.
What results can marketing companies expect when targeting CPA firms?
Modern CPA booked approximately 10 meetings per month, generating so much pipeline demand that they had to hire another sales rep to handle the volume. The key was targeting firms in the 3-to-10 CPA sweet spot and using growth signals like hiring activity to identify firms actively investing in expansion.
Is outbound effective for reaching conservative professional services buyers?
Yes, when messaging earns credibility from the first touchpoint. Accounting firm partners are naturally skeptical of marketing pitches. Modern CPA's campaign used peer-level positioning and verifiable revenue outcomes to build trust, achieving a 24% reply rate and 30 meetings in 3 months with a notoriously cautious buyer audience.
MORE CASE STUDIES
More Cold Email results
See how other B2B teams turned outbound into booked meetings.
TORTOISE FINANCE
MERGERS & ACQUISITIONS
$200k+
Net profit in 2 years
4
new clients in 6 months
Strategy
Healthcare practice owners don't respond to generic M&A outreach. They're protective of what they've built and skeptical of anyone who doesn't understand their world. We started by mining intent signals: practice owners searching for valuation content, updating LinkedIn profiles after 20+ years in practice, or engaging with retirement planning resources. From there, we built segmented lists by specialty and practice size, then wrote outreach that spoke their language. Not "exit strategy optimization," but "what your practice is actually worth and how to protect your staff through a transition." Email infrastructure was routed through a private Microsoft Azure U.S. IP to ensure deliverability into healthcare-heavy inboxes that tend to run aggressive spam filtering. We also staggered send cadences to mirror how a trusted advisor would follow up, not a sales machine. LinkedIn outreach targeted practice owners with personalized engagement around succession planning content, building familiarity before any direct pitch. The result was a pipeline of practice owners who came to the table already educated on Tortoise's approach, which compressed sales cycles and produced 4 signed clients in the first 6 months, adding $200K+ in net annual cashflow.
Read The Full Case Study →
"Because of the processes that Outbound System has developed and put into place, we have been fortunate to have cashflow of multiple six figures per year now. It's been a real game changer type of a gain that we've been fortunate to experience."
Monil Shah
Managing Partner at TORTOISE FINANCE

THOMAS PRODUCTIONS
VIDEO PRODUCTION
52
meetings booked in 4 months
37%
Reply Rate
Strategy
Real estate and private equity firms invest heavily in property presentation, but most still rely on photography and static virtual tours. Thomas Productions creates video content that moves properties faster, and the outbound challenge was getting that message in front of brokerages and PE firms before they defaulted to their existing production vendors. We built prospect lists targeting real estate brokerages handling premium listings and private equity firms with active real estate portfolios, the accounts where video's impact on sale speed and price justifies the investment. Cold email messaging was structured around a specific outcome: properties with professional video sell faster. Sequences included examples from comparable brokerages showing reduced days-on-market and higher closing prices when video was part of the listing strategy. LinkedIn outreach targeted managing brokers and marketing directors at the same firms, engaging with their property posts and sharing video production insights that demonstrated Thomas Productions' understanding of the luxury market. The approach worked because it wasn't selling video production. It was selling faster sales cycles and higher returns. The campaign maintained a 37% reply rate and booked 52 meetings in 4 months, with prospects consistently converting to calls because the value proposition was tied directly to their revenue model.
Read The Full Case Study →
"It's been easy to set appointments with your leads and some have converted to clients."
Alec Valas
Sales Director at THOMAS PRODUCTIONS


